Renewing Wedding Vows With A Real Wedding!

My husband & I have been together for almost 9 years & married for almost 5. 2008 was an extremely rocky year for us. We where seperated for most of the year. We are now back together and considering renewing our vows on our 5 year anniversary in March. We where married in front of a judge the first time and would love to have a REAL wedding. The judge was great and let us personalize the ceremory but its not the same. What do you think?