Nice (but Inexpensive) Reception Sites

We are doing a destintion wedding, and we are going all out and having just close friends and family join us. This is where the bulk of our budget will be spent. We would like to have a nice, inexpensive, and fairly casual reception when we get home, however, so that we can invite the rest of our family and friends to celebrate with us. Any ideas? P.S. We live in a suburb of West Cleveland if anyone reading is from that area.